I've mentioned in my previous post that in Buffy, we didn't actually see enough of Angel (pre-Angelus revival). Sure, I was attracted to his mysteriousness and his brooding, but we weren't let in on his character. Not that Spike did any better in the earlier seasons, especially since he wasn't supposed to last too long in the show.
After Angel branched out to Angel and Spike became a more permanent fixture in Buffy, things got more interesting. We get to see who Angel(us) is and how much he's willing to give to help the helpless. We also get to see how adorable Spike is when he's in love with Buffy. Spike is definitely the breakout character in the universe, so if we're just talking about character development, Spike is the runaway winner. However, I'm very interested in the fact that pre-chip, soulless Spike is very tame compared to Angelus; this makes me think that character-wise, we can dig much deeper into Angel(us).
We can't really compare their relationships with Buffy, since it was more about Buffy growing up than Angel or Spike themselves. Angel's relationship was all about romance. It was both of their first loves. It was very romantic and innocent -- well up until Angel achieved that moment of true happiness and lost his soul and turned evil and tried to kill everyone. Spike's relationship was definitely not about innocence or romance. It was physical and maybe even a little toxic to both of them. Buffy admitted it herself, she was using him. Not that he minded.
Tall, dark, and forehead. |
So, Angel or Spike? I really can't choose. I agree with Buffy. Have them wrestle it out, with oil of some kind involved. I'm sure there are fanfictions on this...right? (To Google I go!)
In my opinion, there can only be one clear winner: Spike.
ReplyDeleteSuperficially, Spike is more aesthetically pleasing and has that Anthony Head-inspired accent.
As a human, Spike wrote poetry; whereas Angel's claim to fame was drunkenness and the unwillingness to work.
Angel's love for Buffy was based on her looks. (He saw her outside the high school in LA.) To prove his love for Buffy, Spike goes through hell (literally and in the form of torture) to procure a soul.
Spike killed two slayers. I am unsure of Angel's stats on this point.
Lastly, his need to protect Buffy was so profound that Spike died to help save the world.